Refusal of Medical Attention

Applies to adult and pediatric patients

Criteria

  • To be utilized when a person with an actual or potential injury or other medical problem is encountered by EMS personnel and wishes to refuse indicated care or transport
  • In the absence of a demonstrated and documented impairment, adults and parents of children have a right to refuse treatment for themselves and their minor children
  • Providers have the responsibility to provide informed consent for the refusal
  • Agency and regional policies and procedures may augment these minimum protocols
  • Medical control should be contacted for transport refusals of patients with an Apparent Life Threatening Event (ALTE) / Brief Resolved Unexplained Events (BRUE) – see protocol
  • Patients with the following should be considered “high risk” – consider medical control
  • Age greater than 65 years or less than 2 months
  • Pulse >120 or <50
  • Systolic blood pressure >200 or <90
  • Respirations >29 or <10
  • Serious chief complaint (including, but not limited to, chest pain, shortness of breath, syncope, and focal neurologic deficit)
  • Significant mechanism of injury or high index of suspicion
  • Fever in a newborn or infant under 8 weeks old

All levels

  • May cancel an ambulance only when there is no indication of a potential illness or injury
  • A CFR may not initiate a refusal of care when there is a person who appears to have an injury or illness

EMT and up

  • Patients who have the medical decision-making capacity (ability to understand the nature and consequences of their medical care decision) and wish to refuse care/transport may do so after the provider has:
  • Determined the patient exhibits the ability to understand the nature and consequences of refusing care/transport (See below)
  • Offered transport to a hospital
  • Explained the risks of refusing care/transport
  • Explained that by refusing care/transport, the possibility of serious illness, permanent disability, and death may increase
  • Advised the patient to seek medical attention and gave instructions for follow-up care
  • Confirmed that the patient understood these directions
  • Left the patient in the care of a responsible adult (when possible)
  • Advised the patient to call again with any return of symptoms or if he or she wishes to be transported

Medical control

  • Assistance with high risk, difficult, or unclear situations

Key points

  • The evaluation of any patient refusing medical treatment or transport should include the following:
  • Visual assessment – To include responsiveness, level of consciousness, orientation, obvious injuries, respiratory status, and gait
  • Initial assessment – Airway, breathing, circulation, and disability
  • Vital signs – (If patient allows) pulse, blood pressure, and respiratory rate and effort; pulse oximetry and/or blood glucose, when clinically indicated
  • Focused exam – As dictated by the patient’s complaint (if any)
  • Medical decision-making determination is defined as follows:
  • Patients at the scene of an emergency who demonstrate the ability to understand the nature and consequences of their medical care decisions shall be allowed to make decisions regarding their medical care, including refusal of evaluation, treatment, or transport
  • A patient, who is evaluated and found to have any one of the following conditions shall be considered incapable of making medical decisions regarding care and/or transport and should be transported to the closest appropriate medical facility under implied consent:
  • Altered mental status from any cause
  • Age less than 18 unless an emancipated minor or with legal guardian consent
  • Attempted suicide, danger to self or other, or verbalizing suicidal intent
  • Acting in an irrational manner, to the extent that a reasonable person would believe that the capacity to make medical decisions is impaired
  • Unable to verbalize (or otherwise adequately demonstrate) an understanding of the illness and/or risks of refusing care
  • Unable to verbalize (or otherwise adequately demonstrate) rational reasons for refusing care despite the risks
  • No legal guardian available (in person or by telephone) to determine transport decisions
  • Patient consent in these circumstances is implied, meaning that a reasonable and medically capable adult would allow appropriate medical treatment and transport under similar conditions
  • Law enforcement should be considered, if needed, to facilitate safe management of patients who lack capacity and require involuntary transport
  • Capacity is a clinical decision, therefore, it is not necessary for law enforcement to place a patient in their “protective custody” in order to safely manage those whom lack capacity and require transportation for further evaluation and treatment
Collaborative 26.2 · pp. 176–177BLS version